Listen and Subscribe
Podcast Transcript
Before radio, television, and the internet, Americans packed theaters to see comedians, singers, dancers, acrobats, magicians, animal acts, and just about anything else that could hold an audience’s attention.
For decades, this fast-moving form of entertainment was one of the biggest businesses in the country.
It created stars, shaped popular culture, and served as a training ground for many of the performers who would later dominate Hollywood.
Learn more about the rise and fall of Vaudeville on this episode of Everything Everywhere Daily.
Following the Civil War, American entertainment options were severely limited, leaving few choices in an era before modern sports, radio, and movies.
Entertainment largely consisted of beer halls and concert saloons. These shows largely focused on attracting men from the urban working class. These men wouldn’t mind the cursing or the sawdust-covered floors that absorbed spilled booze and tobacco spit.
These establishments made much of their money selling alcohol to predominantly male audiences, while prevailing Victorian social conventions discouraged respectable middle-class women from attending.
Audiences participated by shouting, singing along, pounding tables, clapping, and even throwing food at failing acts.
These venues found themselves in the crosshairs of the temperance movement for many of their practices, but the one that caused the most concern was the “waiter girls.”
To moral reformers, these saloons were a scandal. The burlesque routines, the commission-driven waiter girls in scant outfits, and the private back rooms were seen as a straight pipeline to prostitution.
To address these concerns and avoid moral reformers’ wrath, a new wave of shows emerged under the guidance of a showman named Tony Pastor. In 1881, Pastor opened the famed Fourteenth Street Theatre in New York City and hoped to cater to a wider audience, women and children.
Pastor made his shows family-friendly, outlawing smoking, drinking, and foul language. Historians often identify Pastor’s transformation of variety entertainment into respectable family fare as a key moment in the birth of American vaudeville.
In 1883, Benjamin Franklin Keith, a former apprentice of circus tycoon P.T. Barnum, opened a dime museum in Boston dedicated to human oddities and hosting shows. Disappointed with the profits, Keith abandoned the matinee model and initiated the continuous performance model.
Rather than a show every few hours, which generated limited revenue, the continuous model emphasized constant ticket sales, with shows running in a continuous loop throughout the day.
Word of mouth from an early show rippled through the afternoon, pulling in passing crowds off the street.
The shows relied on an eclectic mix, designed to appeal to everyone, regardless of social class. This type of show became known as vaudeville.
The word vaudeville probably comes from the French “voix de ville,” meaning “voice of the city,” referring to popular urban songs. It may also have been influenced by Vau de Vire, a region in Normandy associated with satirical songs. By the 19th century, the French term vaudeville meant light theatrical entertainment with songs, and Americans later adopted the term for variety shows.
A vaudeville setlist followed a strict formula. Each act was between 10 to 15 minutes. Each performer had a bit that they would do over and over, sometimes multiple times a day, for years. It was common for someone with a short vaudeville to travel around the country performing the same brief bit over and over.
The weakest acts were at the beginning and end of the show to accommodate arrivals and departures.The early part of the set featured pantomimes, slapstick physical comedy, or lesser-skilled acrobats. As the momentum built, singers and dancers took center stage.
Vaudeville’s music catered to the unconventional, emphasizing barbershop-style harmonizing and featuring novelty acts, such as one-man bands. Someone who played drums, accordion, tuba, and cymbals all at the same time.
Others played outlandish contraptions: bowing a musical saw, striking tuned bottles of water, or blaring the ‘bazooka’, a homemade pipe-and-funnel horn whose flatulent tones later lent its name to the WWII rocket launcher.
Some popular mid-show acts included musicians who produced loud sounds by changing the shape of their mouths while being slapped, or the wizards of the xylophone, who used up to six mallets simultaneously while leaping and dancing.
After the musical interlude came the acrobats, the jugglers, and the airborne performers who wowed the audience with their trapeze skills. One such act was the Flying Jordans, a trapeze troupe that perfected death-defying feats and somersaults, all without safety equipment.
Few acts gained as much attention as Lillian Leitzel, the Queen of the Air, who performed on Roman rings. Leitzel’s finale involved a “one-arm swingover” in which she hung by one wrist high above the stage, repeatedly throwing her entire body over her shoulder in rapid succession, up to 100 times, dislocating and resetting her shoulder joint with every rotation
While not as awe-inspiring, jugglers gained great acclaim during Vaudeville shows and often used it as a springboard to a greater stage, such as W.C. Fields, who dressed as a tramp while juggling hats, cigar boxes, and billiard balls.
While he didn’t reach Hollywood fame like W.C. Fields, Enrico Rastelli was the most famous juggler of the Vaudeville age. Rastelli juggled ten balls while simultaneously spinning a soccer ball on a mouth stick.
Building off the success of circuses, Vaudeville also incorporated astonishing animal acts. Remarkable exhibits included roller-skating chimpanzees in top hats, wrestling bears, a baboon brass band, and boxing kangaroos.
Despite this star-studded lineup, the undisputed headliner was Beautiful Jim Key, a celebrated horse who stunned crowds by spelling words with letter tiles, solving basic arithmetic, and counting out change from dollar bills.
The sensation he and the other famed animals of Vaudeville created led to the rapid growth of the American Humane Movement, the forerunner to the modern Humane Society.
Another act many vaudeville shows might include would be illusionists, mentalisst, or magicians. In any such discussion, you have to mention Harry Houdini.
Before he achieved international fame, Houdini worked his way up the Vaudeville circuits. The New York Clipper described the growing enthusiasm for Houdini’s work at the time, noting:
Houdini holds the place of honor on the bill at Keith’s Union Square this week, and he is packing the house to the doors at every performance. His work is clean, sharp, and without that air of heavy pretense which ruins so many illusionists.
On Tuesday afternoon he accepted challenges from three separate spectators, escaping from a regulation police straitjacket and two pairs of English figure-eight irons in less than eight minutes total time. The enthusiasm was deafening.
Modern depictions of magicians often lean on Vaudevillian clichés such as sawing women in half, catching bullets, or dodging knives.
A typical Vaudeville show closed with a one-act dramatic play, presented as a buffer to accommodate early departures.
Its variety format created a non-stop entertainment machine, and Keith’s empire outgrew its modest origins. In 1894, he opened the nation’s first true ‘theatrical palace’ in Boston. The palace featured marble columns, crystal chandeliers, and luxurious upholstery.
By moving the shows into such a upscale venue, Benjamin Franklin Keith hoped to capitalize on a more refined audience. The editorial board of the Boston Globe didn’t share Keith’s vision, as they noted:
“The age of luxury seems to have reached its ultima thule. The truth of this has never been impressed upon one so forcibly as in a visit to Keith’s dream palace of a theatre… It is almost incredible that all this lavish magnificence, with its wrought iron, Siena marble, and incandescent light, should be dedicated to variety.”
Despite the criticism, Keith’s palace became the standard for vaudeville venues.
The affluent appreciated familiar creature comforts, and theatre owners gambled that the working class would pay a little more if the venue itself were part of the experience.
As Keith built his dominance in the East, competing theater managers launched a coast-to-coast chain of “Orpheums.” Named after Orpheus, the legendary Greek musician, these grand theatrical palaces rapidly opened across the country.
The lavish architecture wasn’t the only thing Keith and his business partner, Edward Albee, standardized; they soon imposed rigid, uniform contracts on the acts filling their stages. These rigid contracts often didn’t apply equally to Vaudeville’s performers.
Behind the star-studded lineup that made Vaudeville a national sensation lay a complicated hierarchy that reflected the circumstances of late 19th- and early 20th-century urban America.
In the decades after the Civil War, millions of European immigrants poured into East Coast cities, fundamentally reshaping the country’s cultural fabric. This was a double-edged sword for Vaudeville. The new arrivals brought many unique talents and stacked the lineups of touring shows and residencies.
On the other hand, vaudeville routines perpetuated stereotypes of recent immigrants, depicting Irish, Jewish, German, and Italian performers as drunken brawlers, tight-fisted peddlers, or heavily accented newcomers.
However, second-generation artists such as George M. Cohan and the Marx Brothers gradually abandoned those exaggerated accents, leveraging the vaudeville stage to achieve national stardom and broader cultural acceptance.
Black artists faced a far harsher reality. As Vaudeville expanded alongside the rise of Jim Crow, opportunities remained strictly limited. Drawing its comedic foundation from nineteenth-century blackface minstrel shows, the industry largely excluded Black performers.
The white-run circuits enforced a strict racial quota, rarely booking more than one Black act on a standard nine-act bill. Even a genius like Bert Williams, one of the highest-earning recording artists in the country, was required by white booking managers to smear his skin with burnt cork and adopt the dialect of minstrel shows.
Offstage, Williams was forced to ride freight elevators, sleep in segregated boarding houses, and bypass the front doors of the very theaters where his name was on the marquee.
The Keith and Orpheum circuits abused and underpaid their Black performers, prompting the creation of a separate touring network, the Theater Owners Booking Association, or TOBA, in 1909.
Emerging at the height of the Great Migration of African Americans from rural to urban areas, T.O.B.A. formed an alternative circuit primarily across the South and Midwest, sidestepping mainstream vaudeville to stage shows for Black audiences.
While Northern and Southern circuits alike forced Black patrons into segregated balconies, venues on the TOBA circuit staged all-Black bills that launched icons like Bessie Smith, Ma Rainey, and Louis Armstrong.
Just as vaudeville reached its high point and became a powerful money-making machine, it began to decline, and its collapse was swift and decisive.
For decades, the circuit relied on the massive expense of moving thousands of performers and freight cars of scenery across the country. But by the late 1920s, that touring model ran headlong into the modern era.
The early twentieth century brought a revolution in entertainment technology, highlighted by nickelodeons, short films projected onto a screen for a nickel. The allure of live acts faded as audiences grew curious about seeing many of the same things on a screen.
Vaudeville tried to respond by adding film segments at the beginning and end of shows during the “chaser” sections, when people arrived late and left early, but it didn’t stop the exodus of its fan base.
In 1927, the first feature-length motion picture with synchronized sound, The Jazz Singer, was released, and with that, Hollywood effectively ended the Vaudeville era.
On top of that, radio entered American living rooms for free. Household names like Jack Benny, Eddie Cantor, and the Marx Brothers took to the airwaves and reached millions in a single evening at a fraction of the cost of a live show.
Vaudeville’s symbolic end came in November 1932, in the midst of the Great Depression, when the Palace Theatre on Broadway, vaudeville’s greatest venue, dropped its live variety shows and switched to a permanent feature-film business model.
While the theatres went dark, vaudeville never truly died. It just migrated. Elements of the vaudeville DNA can be seen in television variety shows, late-night TV programmes, and even stand-up comedy. To that extent, vaudeville helped create the modern entertainment industry.
?